Etsy is built for handmade, vintage and craft supplies; eBay takes almost anything, and it's strongest for used goods and collectibles that buyers search for by brand or model. On a normal sale, Etsy usually costs less. In our examples, its fees came to about 11–13% of the item price against roughly 15–18% on eBay's standard rate. But a sale through Etsy's Offsite Ads can cost more than eBay. And for used items that aren't vintage, handmade or supplies, eBay is the only one of the two that allows them.
Fees were checked on Etsy's and eBay's own pages on November 21, 2026.
What each platform allows
Etsy is selective. Under its Creativity Standards, everything sold must be made, designed, handpicked or sourced by the seller. Reselling mass-produced items isn't allowed, with limited exceptions for items the seller handpicks or sources:
- Vintage items, which Etsy defines as at least 20 years old
- Craft and party supplies
- Curated gift baskets
So a used phone, a pair of current-season sneakers or a box of last year's toys can't go on Etsy. A 1970s camera, a handmade bowl or a bag of beads can.
eBay accepts new and used items of almost every kind, from collectibles and parts to clothing and electronics, within its own rules on prohibited and restricted items. If an item is legal to sell and isn't on eBay's restricted lists, it can usually go there.
Fees side by side
| Etsy | eBay (no eBay Store) | |
|---|---|---|
| Listing fee | $0.20 per listing , again each time it sells | — (see eBay's page for insertion fees beyond free listings) |
| Main fee | 6.5% transaction fee on item + shipping + gift wrap | 13.6% final value fee on item + handling + shipping + sales tax, for most categories, up to $7,500 per item |
| Payment processing | 3% + $0.25 on the order total | Included in the final value fee |
| Per-order fee | — | $0.30 if the order is $10 or less, $0.40 above $10 |
| Ads you can't always avoid | Offsite Ads: 15% , or 12% after $10,000 in sales in 365 days, capped at $100 | — |
| Selling abroad | Set by your shipping options | International fee: 1.65% when the buyer is outside the US |
Sources: Etsy's Fees & Payments Policy and eBay's selling fees page.
Two notes on eBay:
- Rates vary by category. 13.6% is eBay's standard rate for most categories without an eBay Store; some categories, including art and crafts, may differ. Check eBay's fee table for your category.
- Seller performance matters. eBay adds a surcharge to final value fees for sellers rated below its standards.
Fees on the same items
Three hypothetical items, with the buyer paying shipping and the shipping covering your label. Sales tax is left out; both platforms also charge fees on tax, so real fees would be slightly higher.
A vintage camera, $150 + $12 shipping (order total $162)
| Etsy | Etsy, Offsite Ads (12%) | eBay | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listing fee | $0.20 | $0.20 | — |
| 6.5% transaction (× $162) | $10.53 | $10.53 | — |
| Processing (3% × $162 + $0.25) | $5.11 | $5.11 | — |
| Offsite Ads (12% × $162) | — | $19.44 | — |
| Final value fee (13.6% × $162) | — | — | $22.03 |
| Per-order fee | — | — | $0.40 |
| Total fees | $15.84 | $35.28 | $22.43 |
| You keep | $134.16 | $114.72 | $127.57 |
The camera is assumed to be at least 20 years old, so it qualifies as vintage on Etsy. At Etsy's 15% Offsite Ads rate, the ad fee would be $24.30 and the total $40.14.
A handmade candle, $28 + $5.50 shipping (order total $33.50)
| Etsy | Etsy, Offsite Ads (15%) | eBay | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Listing + transaction + processing | $0.20 + $2.18 + $1.26 | same | — |
| Offsite Ads (15% × $33.50) | — | $5.03 | — |
| Final value fee + per-order fee | — | — | $4.56 + $0.40 |
| Total fees | $3.64 | $8.67 | $4.96 |
| You keep | $24.36 | $19.33 | $23.04 |
A used power drill, $45 + $12 shipping (order total $57)
This one can't go on Etsy: it's used, it isn't vintage or handmade, and it isn't a craft supply.
| eBay | |
|---|---|
| Final value fee (13.6% × $57) | $7.75 |
| Per-order fee | $0.40 |
| Total fees | $8.15 |
| You keep | $36.85 |
For items like this, the comparison isn't eBay vs Etsy; it's eBay against other general marketplaces. See where should I sell?
More on that fee in how Offsite Ads work.
Which items fit where
| Item type | Etsy | eBay | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| Handmade goods | Yes, its core | Yes | Etsy's buyers come looking for handmade |
| Vintage (20+ years) | Yes | Yes | Etsy for style-led vintage; eBay for branded or collectible pieces searched by model |
| Craft supplies | Yes | Yes | Both work; compare fees on your price point |
| Used items under 20 years old | No | Yes | eBay or another general marketplace |
| New mass-produced items | No (no reselling) | Yes | eBay |
| Collectibles, parts, electronics | Only if vintage | Yes | eBay buyers often search by exact brand and model |
How buyers search on each
eBay shoppers often know exactly what they want: a specific camera model, a part number, a brand and size. Listings that name the brand, model and condition clearly tend to suit that kind of search.
Etsy shoppers more often search by what an item is and what it's like: "handmade ceramic mug", "vintage brass candle holder", "personalized necklace". Etsy's search matches your title, tags, attributes, category and description, so describing style, material and use matters more there.
That difference shapes how you'd write the same listing on each platform, even when the item is allowed on both.
The same camera, written for each
Here's how the same hypothetical vintage camera might be titled on each platform. These examples are ours:
- eBay: "35mm SLR Film Camera with 50mm f/1.8 Lens, 1980s, Tested, Working". It leads with exactly what the camera is, adds the lens and condition, and uses the terms a collector would type. On a real listing, the brand and model would go right at the front.
- Etsy: "Vintage 1980s 35mm SLR Film Camera with 50mm Lens". It starts with what the item is and its era, then the key details, following Etsy's advice to put the item type first and key details early.
The description changes too. On eBay, buyers want condition details, what's been tested and what's included. On Etsy, they also respond to the story and style: the era, the look, how it might be used or displayed.
Where the fee gap matters most
The fee difference is largest in percentage terms on cheaper items, where eBay's per-order fee and Etsy's fixed fees both weigh more. In our candle example, eBay took 17.7% of the item price against Etsy's 13.0%. On the camera, it was 15.0% against 10.6%. On expensive pieces, Etsy's $100 cap on Offsite Ads also limits the worst case, while eBay's rate drops to 2.35% only on the portion of an item's price above $7,500.
Selling on both
Many sellers use both: Etsy for handmade and vintage pieces, eBay for everything else or for collectibles with a dedicated buyer base. If you list the same item on both, the risk is selling it twice, so end the other listing as soon as one sells and keep one record of what's listed where.
What to do next
- Sort your stock into "allowed on Etsy" (handmade, vintage 20+ years, supplies) and "eBay only".
- For items allowed on both, run your price and shipping through the tables above, and check your Offsite Ads share on Etsy.
- Compare clothing apps in Poshmark vs Mercari vs Depop, and handmade marketplaces in Etsy vs Amazon Handmade.
- Run an item through the Where should I sell this? tool.