You can ask Etsy buyers for an honest review. You can't offer anything in exchange for a positive one, post or arrange fake reviews, or pressure a buyer to change what they wrote. Two sets of rules apply: Etsy's own policies, and the Federal Trade Commission's rule on consumer reviews, in effect since October 21, 2024. The good news is that the allowed methods (good service, a friendly ask and a fast reply to problems) are also the ones that work.

What Etsy's rules say

Etsy's Anti-Shilling Policy bans:

  • Fake reviews, including reviews you write yourself or have others write for you.
  • Incentives for positive reviews: discounts, freebies or anything else offered in return for a good review.

Etsy's Extortion Policy also covers sellers offering extra goods or compensation in exchange for a positive review. Etsy's Seller Handbook notes that these practices may also break consumer protection laws (Understanding Truthful Advertising and Discount Practices).

Etsy's Seller Policy adds rules about the reviews themselves:

  • Buyers can edit their review any number of times within 100 days.
  • Reviews and seller responses may not be about things outside the seller's control, such as a shipping carrier, Etsy or a third party.
  • Reviews and responses may not include shilling or falsely inflate a shop's score, or undermine the integrity of the review system.

What the FTC rule adds

The FTC's Consumer Reviews and Testimonials Rule (16 CFR Part 465) applies to businesses, not to the shoppers who write reviews. In plain terms, it bans:

  • Fake reviews. A business can't write, create or sell reviews that misrepresent who wrote them or their experience. It also can't buy or share them when it knew or should have known they were fake.
  • Paying for a particular opinion. A business can't offer money or other incentives that depend, openly or by implication, on the review being positive (or negative). The FTC's questions and answers say the problem is the condition: asking a buyer to "tell us how much you loved it" in exchange for a coupon is covered even without the word "positive."
  • Undisclosed insider reviews. Owners and managers who review their own business must clearly disclose the relationship, and the rule also covers asking employees or relatives for reviews without disclosure.
  • Review suppression. A business can't use unfounded legal threats, physical threats, intimidation or certain false public accusations to stop a negative review or get it removed.

The FTC also lists what the rule doesn't prohibit: contacting unhappy customers to resolve their problems, and asking satisfied customers to update their reviews.

The rule allows civil penalties for knowing violations. According to the FTC, the penalty can be up to $53,088 per violation (as of December 2025, adjusted yearly). In December 2025, the FTC sent warning letters to 10 companies about possible violations.

Allowed vs not allowed

Here's how the rules apply to messages sellers actually send. The wording is hypothetical.

Message Allowed? Why
"Thanks for your order! If you have a moment, an honest review helps my small shop." Yes A plain request for an honest review
"Is everything OK with your order? If not, reply here and I'll make it right." Yes Resolving a problem is allowed
"Leave a 5-star review and get 20% off your next order." No An incentive tied to a positive review
"Tell us how much you loved it and we'll send a free gift." No Implies the review must be positive
"Please remove your review or I'll report you." No Pressure to suppress a negative review
Asking a friend who never bought anything to leave a review No A fake review

Allowed ways to get more reviews

  1. Ship fast and pack well. A lot of reviews come down to whether the item arrived on time and as described.
  2. Include a thank-you note. Thank the buyer, say how to reach you if anything's wrong, and invite an honest review. Keep it short. Don't mention stars or ratings, and don't attach any offer.
  3. Send one friendly message after delivery. Ask whether everything arrived well, and mention that reviews help. One message is enough; repeated reminders can feel like pressure.
  4. Fix problems before they become reviews. If a buyer reports damage or a mistake, solving it quickly often turns a bad experience into a good one. The FTC rule explicitly allows contacting unhappy customers to resolve their issues.
  5. Make your listings accurate. Clear photos, honest descriptions and real processing times prevent the surprises behind most low reviews.

A sample thank-you note, in hypothetical wording:

Thank you for supporting my small shop! I hope you love your mug. If anything isn't right, message me through Etsy and I'll fix it. If you're happy with it, an honest review helps other shoppers find me.

Reviews aren't just social proof. Etsy says its search ranking includes your shop's average review rating, message response rate and case rate over the past three months (How Great Customer Service Can Improve Your Search Ranking). Etsy describes this as one factor among several, not the whole picture.

Star Seller status doesn't directly affect search order, according to Etsy. Our guide to how Etsy search works in 2026 covers the other factors. The search visibility page in Shop Manager shows where your shop and listings stand.

When you get an unfair review

Report it, if it breaks the rules. Etsy's help article How to Report a Review explains that you can report a review from your shop's reviews in Shop Manager, up to 100 days after the item's estimated delivery date. Etsy gives examples of reviews that break its policies: ones that include private information, obscene, racist or harassing content, or that are only about things outside the seller's control. Etsy reviews the report; a review that follows the policies stays up.

Know what won't be removed. According to Etsy's help page What to Do if You Receive a Negative Review, harsh criticism of an item alone isn't a violation, and Etsy doesn't judge whether a buyer's statements about quality are accurate.

Respond calmly in public. You can post a public response to a review. Etsy's help page suggests keeping it short, professional and focused on your product and service, not the reviewer, and responses must follow the review policies. Etsy's help page also says that once a seller responds, the buyer can't edit the review, so if you're working with the buyer to fix the problem, consider resolving it before you post a response.

Reach out privately first. If the buyer had a real problem, a message offering a fix is allowed and often helps. Don't ask them to remove or change the review as a condition of the fix, and never threaten them.

If several low reviews arrive together and sales slow, our guide to why Etsy sales drop helps you work out what changed.

What to do next

  • Add a short thank-you note to every order that invites an honest review, with no offer attached.
  • Check your post-delivery messages and remove any wording that ties a discount or gift to a review.
  • Read your last three months of reviews and fix any recurring complaint at its source.
  • Open the search visibility page to see how your customer service numbers look.

This guide is general information, not legal advice. If you have questions about your situation, talk to a lawyer.

Frequently asked questions

Can I ask customers to leave a review on Etsy?
Yes. Asking a buyer for an honest review is allowed. What isn't allowed is offering something in return for a positive review, writing or arranging fake reviews, or pressuring a buyer about what they write.
Can I offer a discount for a review on Etsy?
Not for a positive review. Etsy's Anti-Shilling Policy bans incentives for positive reviews, and the FTC's review rule bans incentives that depend on a review being positive or negative. The safest approach is to ask for an honest review and offer nothing in exchange.
Do Etsy reviews affect search ranking?
Yes, as one factor. Etsy says search ranking includes a shop's average review rating, along with message response rate and case rate, over the past three months.
Can I get a bad Etsy review removed?
Only if it breaks Etsy's review policies, for example if it includes private information or harassment, or is only about something outside your control. You can report it within 100 days of the estimated delivery date. Etsy doesn't remove reviews just because they're negative.