A 20% off sale takes much more than 20% of your profit, because your materials, labels and time cost the same whatever the price. In our hypothetical example, a candle that makes $11.46 at full price makes about $6 on a 20% sale, so you'd need roughly 75–90% more orders to earn the same total.
One thing Etsy doesn't spell out: whether its fees are charged on the discounted price or the original price when you run your own sale or promo code. We show the math both ways below. The difference is small next to the discount itself, and you can check it on your own orders.
How Etsy charges fees on sale items
On a normal US sale, Etsy charges:
- a $0.20 listing fee
- a 6.5% transaction fee on the listing price plus shipping and gift wrap
- payment processing of 3% + $0.25 on the total, including sales tax and shipping
Etsy's Fees & Payments Policy describes the transaction fee as a percentage of "the price you display for each listing plus the amount you charge for shipping and gift wrapping." Its other fee pages describe it as the "total order amount" or the "sale price." None of these pages says directly how a sale or promo code you run changes that base. We couldn't confirm it on a real order, so we're not going to state it as fact.
Check it on your own order
- In Shop Manager, open an order where the buyer used your sale or promo code.
- Look at the fee lines for that order (in the order details or your payment account's activity): the transaction fee and the processing fee.
- Divide the transaction fee by 0.065. If the result matches the discounted total (item plus shipping), fees followed the discounted price. If it matches the original total, they didn't.
Etsy-funded coupons are different
Sometimes Etsy sends buyers its own coupons. Those are paid for by Etsy, not you. Etsy says that when a buyer uses an Etsy-funded coupon, you receive the full order amount and pay the same fees as on an order without the coupon (How Etsy Funded Coupons Work).
Everything else in this guide is about discounts you create: sales and promo codes. Etsy lets you set up percentage-off sales and promo codes from 5% to 75% off, fixed-amount discounts, and free-shipping offers, for some or all items and for a set period (How to Set Up Sales and Discounts).
A 20% sale, worked through
We'll use the hypothetical soy candle from our pricing guide:
- Price: $27.00, plus $5.50 shipping, which covers the $5.50 label
- True cost: $12.00 (materials, packaging, 15 minutes of time, overhead)
- Sales tax left out (Etsy's processing fee is also charged on tax, so real fees would be a few cents higher)
At 20% off, the candle drops to $21.60. Here's what you keep, with fees figured both ways:
| Full price | 20% off, fees on discounted price | 20% off, fees on original price | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer pays (item + shipping) | $32.50 | $27.10 | $27.10 |
| Listing fee | $0.20 | $0.20 | $0.20 |
| Transaction fee (6.5%) | $2.11 | $1.76 | $2.11 |
| Processing (3% + $0.25) | $1.23 | $1.06 | $1.23 |
| Etsy fees | $3.54 | $3.02 | $3.54 |
| Minus label and true cost | −$17.50 | −$17.50 | −$17.50 |
| Profit per order | $11.46 | $6.58 | $6.06 |
The two ways of figuring fees are only $0.52 apart. The discount itself is $5.40. That's where the money goes: it comes straight out of your margin, because none of your costs shrank.
A 20% price cut took 42–47% of the profit on this candle ($11.46 down to $6.58 or $6.06).
How many more sales you need
To earn the same total profit during a sale, divide your full-price profit by your sale profit:
- If fees follow the discounted price: $11.46 ÷ $6.58 = 1.74, so you need about 74% more orders.
- If fees stay on the original price: $11.46 ÷ $6.06 = 1.89, so about 89% more orders.
If you'd normally sell 10 candles in a week, the sale needs to bring in roughly 18 to 19 orders just to break even on profit. A sale can still be worth it for other reasons (see below), but it has to bring in a lot of extra orders to pay for itself.
How much can you discount and still hit your profit?
Use the backward method from our pricing guide. Say you want at least $6 profit per candle, even on sale.
If fees follow the discounted price:
- Order total needed = (profit + costs + label + $0.45) ÷ 0.905
- ($6 + $12 + $5.50 + $0.45) ÷ 0.905 = $23.95 ÷ 0.905 = $26.47 (rounded up)
- Minus $5.50 shipping = $20.97 lowest item price
- From $27, that's a maximum discount of $6.03, or about 22%
If fees stay on the original price ($3.54):
- Order total needed = $6 + $12 + $5.50 + $3.54 = $27.04
- Minus $5.50 shipping = $21.54 lowest item price
- Maximum discount $5.46, or about 20%
So a 20% sale just clears the $6 target either way, and anything deeper doesn't. Our Etsy fee calculator can run your own numbers.
Free shipping as a discount
Free-shipping promo codes feel smaller to sellers, but you still pay for the label. On the candle, the buyer pays $27.00, and you pay the $5.50 label yourself:
| Fees on what the buyer paid ($27.00) | Fees on the original total ($32.50) | |
|---|---|---|
| Etsy fees | $3.02 | $3.54 |
| Minus label and true cost | −$17.50 | −$17.50 |
| Profit | $6.48 | $5.96 |
Again, Etsy doesn't state which base applies when you waive shipping with a promo code, so check the fee lines on an order that used one. Either way, free shipping on this candle costs about as much as a 20% sale.
If the sale came through an Offsite Ad, there's another fee on top, figured on the order total; Etsy doesn't say how discounts affect that base either. See how Offsite Ads work.
When a sale is worth it
A sale can make sense when it does a specific job:
- Clearing old stock you'd otherwise never sell, where some profit beats none.
- Rewarding repeat buyers with a code, so the discount goes to people who'd likely buy again.
- Bringing in new buyers during a busy season, if you can handle the extra orders.
It's less likely to pay off on items that already sell well at full price, or when the discount goes below your floor.
Keep discounts truthful
Etsy's guidance on truthful advertising and discount practices says a crossed-out "original" price must be a genuine price you've really offered for a substantial period, with real sales at that price. Don't raise a price briefly so a sale looks bigger, keep sales temporary, and only say "up to X% off" when a meaningful number of items are at or near that discount. Etsy points to the US Guides Against Deceptive Pricing, and its Seller Policy requires sales and discounts to reflect real pricing.
What to do next
- Work out your floor price for your best sellers before planning any sale.
- After your next discounted order, check the fee lines to see which base Etsy used.
- Run your full price and sale price through the Etsy fee calculator.
- For where the rest of the money goes on a small sale, see the hidden costs of a $25 sale.