It depends on whether you're trying to make a profit. If you are, the IRS treats your selling as a business: you can deduct your expenses, but you owe self-employment tax on the profit. If it's a true hobby, the income is still taxable, but you generally can't deduct hobby expenses, and no self-employment tax applies.
There's also a third case many resellers miss: selling your own used things is neither a hobby nor a business, and it's usually not taxed at all. All three are covered below. This is general information, not tax advice; if your situation is complicated, talk to a tax professional.
How the IRS decides
The test is whether you carry on the activity to make a profit. There's no single rule. The IRS regulation on this, 26 CFR 1.183-2, says all the facts count, and no one factor decides it. It lists nine factors. Here they are in plain terms, with what each looks like for a seller:
- How you run it. Do you carry on the activity "in a businesslike manner," with complete and accurate records? Tracking sales and costs, and changing what doesn't work, points toward a business.
- Your expertise. Have you studied how to sell profitably, or asked people who know? Researching pricing, fees and what sells counts.
- Time and effort. Do you put real, regular time into it, especially the parts that aren't fun, like packing, shipping and bookkeeping?
- Whether assets may grow in value. This matters more for things like land than for most online sellers.
- Past success. Have you turned other activities into profitable ones before?
- Your history of profits or losses. Losses in the start-up years don't rule out a business. Losses that go on long past that, with no explanation, point toward a hobby.
- The size of any profits. A small, occasional profit next to big losses doesn't prove much. A substantial profit, even an occasional one, can.
- Your financial situation. If you have plenty of income from elsewhere and the activity mostly produces losses, that can point toward a hobby.
- Personal pleasure. Enjoying it doesn't make it a hobby. But if the activity is mainly recreation, that points toward one.
There's also a safe harbor in the tax code. Under section 183(d), an activity is presumed to be for profit if it made a profit in at least 3 of the last 5 tax years, including the current year. Meeting that test shifts the burden to the IRS to show otherwise. Not meeting it doesn't automatically make your selling a hobby; the factors still decide.
The IRS sums up the difference simply: a business operates to make a profit, while a hobby is done for pleasure or recreation. Its newsroom page on telling a hobby from a business covers the same factors.
Hobby vs business at a glance
| Hobby | Business | |
|---|---|---|
| Is the income taxable? | Yes | Yes, on profit |
| Where it's reported | Schedule 1 (Form 1040), line 8j | Schedule C |
| Self-employment tax | No | Yes, once net earnings reach $400 |
| Can you deduct expenses? | No | Yes, ordinary and necessary business expenses |
| Can a loss reduce your other income? | No | Generally yes, if it's a real business |
The expense rule for hobbies is the one that surprises people. Hobby expenses are treated as miscellaneous itemized deductions, and IRS Publication 17 says they "can no longer be deducted." That suspension began in 2018, and the 2025 tax law (the One, Big, Beautiful Bill Act) continued it with no end date.
Which is better for you?
It depends on your numbers, and the classification isn't a choice you make to lower your tax. It follows from how you actually run things.
That said, here's how the trade-off usually works out. A seller who makes a real profit and has real expenses generally comes out ahead under business rules, because expenses come off before tax, even though self-employment tax applies. A business with a genuine loss can also use it against other income. A hobby pays no self-employment tax, but tax applies to income without most deductions, which hurts when costs are high.
Three examples
These sellers and their numbers are hypothetical.
Rosa, who knits for fun
Rosa knits scarves in the evenings because she enjoys it. A few times a year she sells some at a church craft fair for roughly what the yarn cost her, about $240 in total for the year. She doesn't keep records, doesn't advertise and isn't trying to grow it.
That looks like a hobby. Rosa reports her hobby income on Schedule 1. She owes no self-employment tax, and she can't deduct her hobby expenses.
Jordan, who runs an Etsy shop
Jordan sells candles on Etsy. In 2026 the shop had $12,000 in sales and $7,000 in costs: materials, packaging, Etsy fees and shipping labels. Jordan tracks every sale and expense in a spreadsheet, spends about 15 hours a week on the shop, and has raised prices twice after working out the costs.
That's a business. Jordan reports it on Schedule C, subtracts the $7,000 in costs, and pays tax on the $5,000 profit. Because the profit is over $400, self-employment tax applies too: $5,000 × 92.35% × 15.3% is about $706. Our guide to taxes for online sellers walks through what to set aside and when to pay.
Sam, who flips thrift finds
Sam buys clothes and housewares at thrift stores to resell on Poshmark and eBay. Last year Sam sold $3,000 worth, after paying $1,200 for the items and $500 in fees and shipping.
Buying things specifically to resell for more is a profit-seeking activity, even at this size, so Sam is generally running a small business. The profit is $3,000 − $1,200 − $500 = $1,300, reported on Schedule C. Self-employment tax applies: $1,300 × 92.35% × 15.3% is about $184.
Selling your own stuff is different
Clearing out your closet isn't a hobby or a business. It's selling personal property, and it has its own simple rule.
- Sold for less than you paid: there's no gain, so there's nothing to tax. You also can't deduct the loss. Most used clothes, furniture and household items fall here.
- Sold for more than you paid: the gain is taxable. This can happen with collectibles or items that went up in value.
If a platform sends you a Form 1099-K that includes personal items sold at a loss, you still account for those sales on your return, but they don't become taxable income. Our guide to the 1099-K for 2026 explains how to report them.
The line between this and reselling is why you bought the item. Clothes you bought to wear and later sold are personal items. Clothes you bought at a thrift store in order to sell are inventory.
What to do if you're not sure
If you can't tell which side you're on:
- Keep records as if you're a business. Track every sale, what you paid for items and materials, fees and shipping. Good records help either way, and they're one of the factors the IRS looks at.
- Separate personal sales from items bought to resell. If you do both, note which is which as you go.
- Look at your direction. Are you trying to grow sales and earn more than you spend? That intent, shown by how you act, is the core of the test.
- Talk to a tax professional if your selling has run at a loss for several years, or if the amounts are large enough that the answer changes your tax bill a lot.
What to do next
- Go through the nine factors above and note honestly which way each points for you.
- Set up a simple record of sales and costs for 2026 if you don't have one.
- If you're running a business, read taxes for online sellers for self-employment tax and quarterly payments.
- If you mostly sell your own used things, read the 1099-K for 2026 so a form in January doesn't confuse you.