On fees alone, your own Shopify store gets cheaper than Etsy at a fairly low sales volume. In our example, it's around 14 orders a month. But Etsy's real value is its buyers: people already searching for handmade and vintage items. Your own store starts with no visitors, and bringing them in is the cost that doesn't show up in any fee table. For most small sellers, the practical path is to keep Etsy and add your own store once you have customers who come back.
Below are the fees side by side, the break-even math with the arithmetic shown, and an honest look at the traffic question. Fees were checked on November 21, 2026.
What each costs
Etsy charges per sale, with no monthly fee:
- $0.20 listing fee , charged again each time the item sells
- 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus shipping and gift wrap
- 3% + $0.25 payment processing on the order total, including sales tax
- Offsite Ads, when a sale comes from an ad Etsy runs on another site: 15% of the order, or 12% once your shop has made $10,000 in the past 365 days, capped at $100 per order. Shops over $10,000 can't opt out. See our Offsite Ads guide.
Shopify charges a monthly plan plus card processing on each sale (Shopify pricing):
| Plan | Billed monthly | Billed yearly (per month) | Online card rate with Shopify Payments | Extra fee with another payment provider |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic | $39 | $29 | 2.9% + 30¢ | 2% |
| Grow | $105 | $79 | 2.7% + 30¢ | 1% |
| Advanced | $399 | $299 | 2.5% + 30¢ | 0.6% |
The "extra fee" only applies if you take payments through a provider other than Shopify Payments, and it's on top of that provider's own processing charges. With Shopify Payments, there's no extra fee.
Shopify's pricing page also lists a higher online rate for premium cards: 3.5% + 30¢ on Basic, 3.3% + 30¢ on Grow and 3.1% + 30¢ on Advanced . Premium cards cost more to process, so your real average rate depends on which cards your buyers use. The break-even below uses the standard rate.
The plan isn't the whole cost of a store. A domain name, a paid theme and add-on apps are all optional, but most stores pay for at least some of them. We leave them out of the math below because they vary so much, but count them when you price out your own store.
The break-even point
Here's a hypothetical shop to compare the two.
- Average order: a $35 item plus $5 shipping, so the buyer pays $40.
- We leave sales tax out. Etsy also charges its 3% processing fee on the tax the buyer pays, so Etsy's real fees would be slightly higher than shown here.
- On Shopify, we use the Basic plan with Shopify Payments.
Fees per order
Etsy, normal sale:
| Fee | Calculation | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Listing | flat | $0.20 |
| Transaction | 6.5% × $40 | $2.60 |
| Processing | 3% × $40 + $0.25 | $1.45 |
| Total per order | $4.25 |
Etsy, with Offsite Ads. Say 20% of orders come through an Offsite Ad. That's a hypothetical share; check your own in Shop Manager. Which rate applies depends on your shop's sales over the past 365 days:
- Under $10,000 a year: 15% × $40 = $6.00 on an ad order. Averaged across all orders, that adds 20% × $6.00 = $1.20 per order, for a total of $5.45.
- $10,000 or more a year: 12% × $40 = $4.80 on an ad order. Averaged, that adds 20% × $4.80 = $0.96 per order, for a total of $5.21.
Shopify Basic: 2.9% × $40 + $0.30 = $1.16 + $0.30 = $1.46 per order, plus the monthly plan.
Orders with several different items pay a $0.20 listing renewal for each item sold, so they cost a little more on Etsy than shown here.
Where the lines cross
Each order costs $4.25 on Etsy and $1.46 on Shopify, so Shopify saves $4.25 − $1.46 = $2.79 per order. The plan has to be paid for out of those savings:
- Basic billed monthly ($39): $39 ÷ $2.79 = 13.98, so Shopify is cheaper from 14 orders a month, about $560 in monthly sales.
- Basic billed yearly ($29): $29 ÷ $2.79 = 10.39, so Shopify is cheaper from 11 orders a month, about $440.
- With Offsite Ads at 15% ($5.45 per Etsy order): $5.45 − $1.46 = $3.99 saved per order, and $39 ÷ $3.99 = 9.77, so Shopify is cheaper from 10 orders a month.
Monthly cost at four sales levels
Using Basic billed monthly. Orders = monthly sales ÷ $40, so a $500 month is 12.5 orders on average.
| Monthly sales | Orders | Etsy, no Offsite Ads | Etsy, 20% Offsite Ads | Shopify Basic ($39 + $1.46/order) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| $500 | 12.5 | $53.13 | $68.13 (at 15%) | $57.25 |
| $1,500 | 37.5 | $159.38 | $195.38 (at 12%) | $93.75 |
| $3,000 | 75 | $318.75 | $390.75 (at 12%) | $148.50 |
| $6,000 | 150 | $637.50 | $781.50 (at 12%) | $258.00 |
We used the 15% Offsite Ads rate for the $500 row, because that shop makes about $6,000 a year, under the $10,000 line. The other rows are $18,000 a year and up, so they use 12%.
At $6,000 a month, the fee difference is $637.50 − $258.00 = $379.50 a month before Offsite Ads, or $523.50 with them. That's a real number, and it's why sellers look at Shopify. But it only counts if those same sales happen on your own store, and that's the hard part.
You can check your own Etsy numbers with the Etsy fee calculator.
The cost that isn't in the fee table: traffic
Etsy's fees pay for more than processing. When someone searches Etsy for "personalized dog collar," your listing can show up in front of a buyer who was already looking to buy. Etsy brings the shoppers.
Your own store starts with zero visitors. Nobody finds it unless you send them there, and every way of doing that costs time, money, or both:
- Paid ads on search engines or social media cost money per click or per view, and results vary widely.
- Social media takes steady effort to build an audience, and reach can change without notice.
- Email works well for repeat customers, but you need a list first.
- Search engines can bring free visitors over time, but it often takes months and ongoing work to rank.
We're not going to give you a conversion rate or a traffic number. They vary too much by product, price and audience, and most published figures come from companies selling marketing tools. The honest version: if most of your Etsy sales come from Etsy search, moving them to your own store means replacing that search traffic yourself. Until you can, the fee savings in the table above are theoretical.
A good way to test it: look at where your Etsy orders come from. Etsy's Stats include a breakdown of where your visits came from. Sales that come from your own audience are the ones most likely to follow you to a store.
What you gain with your own store
The fee savings aren't the only reason sellers add a store.
- No Offsite Ads. You decide whether and where to advertise, and what to spend.
- Your customer list. On your own store you get buyers' email addresses (with their permission to market to them), so you can tell them about new products. On a marketplace, the relationship belongs mostly to the platform.
- Your brand, your rules. Your store's design, policies and prices aren't set against competitors on the same search page.
- Less dependence on one platform. A change in Etsy's fees, search or policies affects you less if Etsy isn't your only channel.
There's also more to handle. You're responsible for things a marketplace takes care of, such as sales tax collection and filing in the states where you owe it. See our guide to sales tax for marketplace sellers.
Who should switch, stay, or do both
Stay on Etsy (for now) if most of your orders come from Etsy search, you sell fewer than about 10 to 15 orders a month, or you don't have time to market a store. The fees are higher per sale, but you're paying for buyers you'd otherwise have to find.
Do both if you have repeat customers, a social following, or a mailing list. Keep Etsy for new buyers, and send returning customers to your own store, where each sale costs you less and there's no Offsite Ads fee. This is the most common middle path, and it lets you test a store without giving up Etsy's traffic.
Consider moving most sales to your own store if a large share of your orders already come from your own audience, you're well past the break-even volume, and you're comfortable doing the marketing and admin yourself. Even then, keeping an Etsy shop open can still bring in new customers.
What to do next
- Count your orders and average order value for the past few months, and run the break-even math above with your own numbers.
- In Etsy's Stats, look at the breakdown of where your visits came from. That tells you how much traffic you'd need to replace.
- Check your Offsite Ads charges in Shop Manager, under Marketing, to see what they're really costing you.
- For how Etsy compares with other marketplaces as well, see where should I sell?