How to use this calculator
- Enter your average order: the item price and the shipping you charge. Leave sales tax out.
- Enter how many orders you get a month, on average.
- If some of your Etsy orders come through Offsite Ads, enter that share. You can find it in Shop Manager. Tick the box if your shop has made $10,000 or more in the past 365 days.
- Choose whether you'd pay for Shopify Basic monthly or yearly.
The calculator shows the number of orders a month from which Shopify Basic costs less than Etsy's fees, the fees per order on each side, and both monthly totals at your volume.
How the math works
This is the method from our guide, Shopify vs Etsy: should you leave Etsy for your own store?.
Etsy charges per order, with no monthly fee: a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the item plus shipping, and 3% + $0.25 payment processing. If a share of your orders come from Offsite Ads, that share of one ad order's Offsite Ads fee (15%, or 12% for shops over $10,000 a year, capped at $100 an order) is added to every order as an average.
Shopify Basic with Shopify Payments charges 2.9% + $0.30 per online card order, plus the plan: $39 a month billed monthly, or $29 a month billed yearly.
Each order saves the difference between the two per-order fees, and the plan is paid out of those savings. Divide the plan by the savings per order, and Shopify costs less from the next whole order.
For the guide's $35 item with $5 shipping:
- Etsy: $0.20 + $2.60 + $1.45 = $4.25 per order
- Shopify Basic: 2.9% × $40 + $0.30 = $1.46 per order
- Saved per order: $4.25 − $1.46 = $2.79
- Billed monthly: $39 ÷ $2.79 = 13.98, so Shopify costs less from 14 orders a month
- Billed yearly: $29 ÷ $2.79 = 10.39, so from 11 orders a month
The calculator opens on these numbers, at 37.5 orders a month: the guide's $1,500 month.
What the fee table leaves out: traffic
Etsy's fees pay for more than processing. Etsy puts your listings in front of buyers who are already searching. Your own store starts with no visitors, and every way of bringing them in, such as ads, social media, email or search engines, costs time, money or both. If most of your Etsy sales come from Etsy search, the savings here only become real once your store can replace that traffic.
Our guide covers the traffic question, what you gain with your own store, and who should switch, stay, or do both.
What this calculator leaves out
- Other Shopify plans. It uses Basic only.
- Other payment providers. It assumes Shopify Payments. With another provider, Shopify adds 2% on Basic, on top of that provider's own fees.
- Premium cards. Shopify charges a higher rate for premium cards; this uses the standard online rate.
- Store extras. A domain, a paid theme and apps are optional but common, and they vary too much to include.
- Sales tax. Etsy charges processing on the tax buyers pay, so its real fees are slightly higher than shown.
- Orders with several items. Each extra item sold renews a $0.20 listing on Etsy.
You can check a single Etsy sale in detail with the Etsy fee calculator.